Red flags in "we buy houses" cash offers
Short answer
The main red flags are pressure to sign quickly, contracts that let the buyer assign the deal to someone else or cancel while you cannot, very small earnest money deposits, deductions and fees revealed late, a memorandum recorded against your title, and sale-leaseback deals you do not fully understand. Those come from ProPublica's reporting, the FTC and North Carolina's attorney general.123
Red flags in the contract
ProPublica's 2023 investigation lists terms that experts point to:1
- a statement that the buyer intends to profit from a below-market price;
- the right to assign the contract to another buyer;
- deductions for unpaid debts or fees taken from the final price;
- cancellation rights for the buyer only;
- hidden closing costs;
- a very small earnest money deposit;
- a memorandum of the sale recorded with the county that clouds your title and makes it hard to sell to anyone else.
The experts ProPublica interviewed called title-clouding tactics predatory, though such tactics are generally legal unless fraud or elder abuse is proven.1
Red flags in how the deal is pitched
- Pressure. The FTC says to walk away from anyone pushing you to decide immediately.2
- Terms that change. If the contract differs from what was promised or is too complicated to follow, stop.2
- Promises to pay off your mortgage quickly or sell for you, while asking you to sign over ownership first. North Carolina's attorney general warns that some "we buy homes" companies are unlikely to pay cash or quickly pay off a mortgage, and to be wary of transferring ownership based on promises.3
- Sale-leaseback offers. You sell and rent the home back. The FTC notes that you become a renter, the rent can rise, and you could lose the home if you fall behind.2
Protect yourself
- Do not sign on the spot. Have a lawyer or trusted person review the documents.2
- Know your home's value: online estimates, an agent's free market analysis or an appraisal.1
- Consider a title report to see what debts or liens exist.1
- If you are behind on payments, talk to your lender and to a HUD-approved housing counselor before selling.13
- Get at least two offers, and compare them with listing the house: Clean it or sell it as-is.
If you think a buyer acted deceptively, contact your state attorney general's consumer protection office.
Sources
- ProPublica. Looking to Sell Your Home for Cash? Read This First.. May 17, 2023.
- FTC Consumer Advice. Risky business: offers to cash out your home equity through a sale-leaseback. October 3, 2024.
- North Carolina Department of Justice. "We Buy Homes" Scams. January 13, 2021.