Police raided my rental and damaged it. Who pays?
Short answer
Often the owner does, at least at first. Two federal appeals courts have ruled that the Constitution's Takings Clause does not require a city to pay for damage police caused while handling an armed suspect in an emergency, even when the owner did nothing wrong.21 Minnesota's Supreme Court reached the opposite result under its state constitution.4 Start with your own insurer and a written claim to the city or agency; if federal agents did the damage, the claim goes on Standard Form 95 within two years.5
This page is about damage from a raid, a warrant served by force, or a standoff: broken doors and windows, gas canisters, residue from chemical agents, and the mess left behind. It applies whether the person police were looking for was a tenant, a tenant's guest, or a stranger who ran into the house.
What the courts have said
The question in these cases is whether wrecking an innocent person's property to stop a dangerous suspect counts as a government "taking" that has to be paid for.
- Lech v. Jackson (10th Circuit, 2019). An armed suspect barricaded himself in a Colorado family's home. During a standoff of about 19 hours, officers fired gas munitions into the house, breached it with an armored vehicle and used explosives, leaving it uninhabitable. The court held that when the state acts under its police power, rather than eminent domain, its actions are not a taking.1
- Baker v. City of McKinney (5th Circuit, 2023). An armed fugitive held a 15-year-old inside a Texas home. Police used armored vehicles, explosives and toxic-gas grenades, and the damage came to about $50,000. The court held that the Takings Clause does not require compensation when it was objectively necessary for officers to damage the property in an active emergency.2
- The Supreme Court declined to hear Baker in November 2024. Justice Sotomayor, joined by Justice Gorsuch, wrote that the denial says nothing about the merits and that the case raises "a serious question" that would benefit from more consideration in the lower courts.3
- Wegner v. Milwaukee Mutual (Minnesota, 1991). Police fired at least 25 tear gas rounds and three flash-bang grenades into a Minneapolis house where a suspect was hiding. Minnesota's Supreme Court held that damage police cause to an innocent third party's property while apprehending a suspect is a compensable "damaging" under the Minnesota Constitution, and that the city had to reimburse the owner.4
So the answer depends on where the house is and which law applies. Lech and Baker bind federal courts in their circuits; Wegner applies in Minnesota. We did not survey every state's constitution, and some state constitutions, like Minnesota's, mention property that is "damaged" as well as "taken".4 A local lawyer can tell you which rule applies to your house.
These cases involved emergencies with armed suspects. A raid that went to the wrong address, or damage beyond what the situation required, raises different questions, and none of the rulings above decided those.
Steps to take
- Document before anything is touched. Photos and video of every room, the doors, windows, walls and any canisters or residue. Keep the case or incident number.
- Call your insurer. In the Minnesota case, the owner's insurer paid part of the structural and glass repairs, then sued the city to recover them.4 Whether your policy covers police damage depends on its wording; ask the insurer to point to the exclusion if it says no. Landlord policies are covered on Landlord insurance and cleanup.
- File a written claim with the city or agency. Ask the city attorney's or risk management office how claims are filed and whether there is a deadline. Even where courts have refused takings claims, some cities offer help; in Lech, the city offered temporary housing assistance while denying liability.1
- If federal agents did it (for example, the FBI, DEA or U.S. Marshals), claims against the federal government go on Standard Form 95, "Claim for Damage, Injury or Death," filed within two years of when the claim arose.5
- Ask about victim compensation only if someone in the household was a crime victim. These programs pay for victims' losses under each state's own rules, and some cover crime scene cleanup; whether anything after a raid qualifies is a question for your state's program. Check your state on Victim compensation for cleanup.
Tear gas and chemical residue
Police commonly use riot control agents such as CS and CN. The CDC lists effects on the eyes, lungs and skin, and its advice for exposed people is to get away from the source, wash skin with plenty of soap and water, and seal contaminated clothing in a plastic bag inside a second bag.6
The CDC page is about people, not houses, and we did not find federal guidance on cleaning a home after tear gas. Our view: for anything beyond light residue, get an estimate from a restoration or biohazard company and ask how it handles fabrics and the heating and cooling system. If you clean any of it yourself, ventilate, wear gloves and eye protection, and bag fabrics the way the CDC describes for clothing. Leave if your eyes or breathing start to react.
Landlord and tenant questions
- Is the tenant responsible? If the tenant or a guest's conduct led to the raid, the landlord may have a claim against the tenant under the lease and state law; see Tenant liability for guest damage. If the tenant had nothing to do with it, the tenant is also a person whose home was damaged.
- Is the unit livable? A unit with broken doors, windows or heavy chemical residue may not meet habitability rules until it is repaired. The rights on both sides are covered on Tenant rights after contamination.
- Drugs or needles left behind after a drug raid: see Needles or drugs left behind. If police found a meth lab, state meth cleanup rules apply before anyone moves back in: Meth disclosure by state.
Expect to pay for the repairs yourself up front and recover what you can afterward. The order that makes recovery most likely: photos first, then your insurer, then a written claim to whichever government agency did the damage, all with dates and receipts.
Sources
- U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit. Lech v. Jackson, No. 18-1051 (10th Cir. Oct. 29, 2019). 2019-10-29.
- U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit (via Justia). Baker v. City of McKinney, No. 22-40644 (5th Cir. Oct. 11, 2023). 2023-10-11.
- Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School. Baker v. City of McKinney, No. 23-1363, certiorari denied (Nov. 25, 2024), statement of Sotomayor, J.. 2024-11-25.
- Minnesota Supreme Court (via Justia). Wegner v. Milwaukee Mutual Insurance Co., 479 N.W.2d 38 (Minn. 1991). 1991.
- U.S. National Archives, Office of General Counsel. Tort Claims (Federal Tort Claims Act, Standard Form 95).
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Facts About Riot Control Agents.