A tenant is hoarding. What can a landlord do?
Short answer
Hoarding can meet the fair housing definition of a disability, so a landlord who knows or should know about it generally has to try a reasonable accommodation, such as extra time to bring the unit up to code, before terminating the lease, according to Virginia's Fair Housing Office.1 Minimum health and safety standards still have to be met, and the office recommends a written plan of action that documents the landlord's efforts.1
Fair housing basics
Virginia's Fair Housing Office guidance for housing providers says:1
- Hoarding is a mental impairment that, in most cases, limits major life activities such as caring for oneself, so it can meet the fair housing definition of disability.
- A resident who hoards can request a reasonable accommodation even without using those words.
- An accommodation may be an extension of time to bring the unit up to housing codes before lease termination or eviction.
- If the provider knew or should have known about the hoarding, the law requires attempts to reasonably accommodate before evicting.
- Minimum health and safety standards must still be met.
- A written plan of action, included with the accommodation offer, helps hold the resident accountable and documents the provider's efforts.
Fair housing law is federal, but state and local laws add to it; check yours.
A practical sequence for landlords
- Inspect with proper notice under your lease and state law, and document conditions with photos.
- Identify the safety issues specifically (blocked exits, items near heat sources, pests, plumbing).2
- Meet with the tenant, offer reasonable time and a written plan with dated steps and re-inspections.
- Point to help. See Help for hoarding disorder.
- Re-inspect and document. If standards still are not met after a reasonable accommodation, follow your state's legal process; get legal advice before filing.
For tenants
If your landlord says your unit is unsafe because of clutter, you can ask, in writing, for a reasonable accommodation, such as more time and a step-by-step plan.1 A local fair housing organization or legal aid office can help.
Costs
If the tenant leaves and cleanup is needed, deposit and damage rules apply. See Security deposit and cleanup and Hoarding cleanup cost.
This is general information, not legal advice. For a specific tenancy, a fair housing organization or landlord-tenant attorney can explain how federal, state and local law apply.
Sources
- Virginia Fair Housing Office. Tips for Working with a Resident Who Hoards. Revised June 2020.
- U.S. Fire Administration (FEMA). Hoarding and Fire Safety. Last reviewed April 1, 2023.